Skip to primary navigation Skip to content Skip to footer
Back to RailLines Blog

EXPERIENCE LIVE THEATER IN LANCASTER, PA: 9 OF THE BEST THEATERS FOR LIVE ENTERTAINMENT 

A performer for the murder mystery standing stealthily along an inside train door.

Lancaster, PA has become an increasingly popular location to experience live theatre. From historic performing halls to experimental venues, there are plenty of live entertainment options to choose from. Below are nine of our favorite live theatre spots near Lancaster County. 

1. Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre

Rediscover the tradition of dinner theatre at The Dutch Apple. Owned by the Prather family, who has been producing live theatre in Lancaster for over 50 years, the Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre offers Broadway-style shows over a freshly cooked meal. 

The dinner theatre is comfortable, seating only 328 guests per show, but they host over 150,000 guests a year. Choose from their dining options of a classic dinner buffet, table service dinner, or enhanced dinner buffet as you take in a stimulating live performance!

Previous Shows

  • Beauty and the Beast
  • Mamma Mia
  • Grease
  • Peter Pan
  • Elf The Musical

Check out the shows that are playing this season at the Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre. 

Address

501 Centerville Road

Lancaster, PA 17601

2. American Music Theatre

If you’re interested in more than live theatre, The American Music Theatre offers over 200 different live entertainment options in Lancaster, PA yearly. From Broadway tours, comedy performances, live music, and celebrity concerts, the American Music Theatre has one of the most diverse and lengthy entertainment schedules along the East Coast. 

They are a high-caliber performance venue, and they’ve been recognized with several awards and nominations over the years. They’ve even hosted Grammy, CMA, Tony, and Oscar award winners, which is a testament to the America Music Theatre’s professionalism.

Previous Shows

  • Scotty McCreery
  • Celtic Women
  • Jay Leno
  • RAIN – A Tribute to The Beatles
  • The Oak Ridge Boys

Check out the shows that are playing this season at the American Music Theatre. 

Address

2425 East Lincoln Highway

Lancaster, PA 17602

3. Fulton Theatre

The historic Fulton Theatre is 1 of 8 theatres in the United States that is recognized as a National Historic Landmark. It was purchased as a not-for-profit building in 1962 by concerned citizens to save it from demolition. 

Since then, the Fulton Theatre has been offering a range of productions, from large-scale to small, in their stunning Victorian-style opera house. Their goal is to “create and produce exceptional theatre” — and they offer just that to Lancaster and its surrounding areas.

Previous Shows

  • Jersey Boys
  • Treasure Island
  • Chicago
  • Kinky Boots
  • Peter Pan

Check out the shows that are playing this season at the Fulton Theatre. 

Address

12 North Prince Street

Lancaster, PA 17603

A group of performers on a stage posing for the camera with instruments and flashy outfits.

4. Prima Theatre

Since its founding in 2010, the Prima Theatre has been offering unique themed theater to the Lancaster area. They host boutique musicals, theatrical concerts, and other special events in an effort to attract more than just the frequent performing-art-goers. 

Many of Prima’s returning guests are decades younger than the national average of theatre attendees, which speaks to their success in creating an invigorating performance venue. If you’re searching for some unique live theatre in Lancaster, add the Prima Theatre to your list!

Previous Shows

  • Billy Joel Cabaret
  • Music of West Side Story
  • Retro Sounds
  • Sinatra Holiday Speakeasy
  • The Music of Queen+Journey
Murder Mystery Train Experience From $75

Guests are traveling by rail for the big premiere of a new Broadway show and to attend an intimate reception with its star. As the train departs, guests are treated to drinks from the bar, hors d’oeuvres, and soon after, a body. Who could the killer be? The high-powered press agent, the famous actor, her jealous manager, or even the barman? It’s anyone’s guess!